From the Department of Ophthalmology, Scheie Eye Institute, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia (Drs Jacobson, Cideciyan, and Bennett); Department of Ophthalmology, University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center, Dean A. McGee Eye Institute, Oklahoma City (Dr Kingsley); and Departments of Ophthalmology(Dr Stone) and Pediatrics and the Howard Hughes Medical Institute (Dr Sheffield), University of Iowa College of Medicine, Iowa City.
To determine the molecular basis of a retinopathy previously described as dominant macular subretinal neovascularization with peripheral retinal degeneration.
The TIMP3 gene was analyzed in family members, and 4 mutation-positive patients were studied using psychophysics and electroretinography.
Cosegregating with disease in the family was a single base pair change in the TIMP3 gene, altering a conserved tyrosine to cysteine at amino acid position 172 (Y172C). There was psychophysical and electroretinographic evidence of rod dysfunction greater than cone dysfunction. Dark adaptometry showed abnormalities with regional retinal variation in degree.
The Y172C mutation in the TIMP3 gene is another cause of Sorsby fundus dystrophy. The expression of this form of the disease, as in other C-terminal TIMP3 mutations, is speculated to be secondary to mutant TIMP-3, causing a decreased turnover of the extracellular matrix.
The molecular clarification of inherited retinal degeneration involving abnormal extracellular matrix turnover in and around Bruch's membrane should provide clues to the pathogenesis of not only these particular diseases but also forms of age-related macular degeneration.
AMONG MANY monogenic retinal degenerative diseases, only Sorsby fundus dystrophy (SFD) commonly manifests as a hemorrhagic maculopathy secondary to choroidal neovascularization (CNV).1 This feature of SFD is interesting because of its clinical similarity to some forms of age-related macular degeneration (AMD). The hypothesis that there may be both molecular and clinical similarity to AMD became testable when it was determined that SFD was caused by mutations in the gene encoding tissue inhibitor of metalloproteinases-3 (TIMP-3),2 an extracellular matrix (ECM) protein. However, candidate gene screening with the TIMP3 gene in AMD populations did not reveal a simple genetic relationship between the rare inherited disease and the common age-related cause of CNV.3,4
The complex pathways leading from the TIMP3mutation to ECM disturbance and CNV are still being studied.5,6 Results are beginning to reveal a pathogenetic sequence that may explain abnormal sub-RPE (retinal pigment epithelium) deposition in a number of retinopathies.5- 7 Studies to understand the effects on ECM turnover of mutant TIMP-3 are aided by the knowledge of disease-causing TIMP3 mutations. Apart from the founder mutation in codon 181 from the British Isles, only a few other disease-causing TIMP3 gene mutations have been identified.6,8
More than a decade ago, a family was described as having "dominant macular subretinal neovascularization with peripheral retinal degeneration."9 Among the diagnostic possibilities considered was SFD, but the age at disease onset was thought to be too early compared with other reports in the literature at that time.10,11 We reevaluated the family and report that this retinopathy is a severe form of SFD caused by a novel mutation in the TIMP3 gene.
Informed consent was obtained from the study participants for all procedures. Mutation screening of the TIMP3 gene was performed. Venous blood samples were collected from 13 family members (generations III and IV in Figure 1A), and DNA was extracted. Techniques for single-strand polymorphism (SSCP) analysis and direct sequencing of polymerase chain reaction (PCR) products have been described elsewhere.12
A, Pedigree of the family in this study. Filled symbols indicate affected individuals; shaded symbols, individuals molecularly affected but clinically unaffected to date; open symbols, unaffected individuals; and slashed symbols, deceased individuals. Patient III-5 is the proband. B, Single-strand polymorphism analysis of TIMP3 exon 5 polymerase chain reaction products in available family members. Each lane of this silver nitrate–stained 6% polyacrylamide gel contains the amplified DNA from the individual whose pedigree number is above it. Individuals with the mutation (+) have 2 extra bands (arrows), indicating a heterozygous exon 5 mutation. Four individuals (−) lack the extra bands, representing a homozygous normal sequence in exon 5. C, Fundus photograph of patient III-5(at age 45 years) showing central retinal scarring and degeneration.
A subset of 4 patients (III-4, 5, and 6 and IV-14), all positive for a TIMP3 gene mutation, were assessed with routine ophthalmic examinations and specialized tests of visual function. Static threshold perimetry in dark-adapted (500- and 650-nm stimuli) and light-adapted (600-nm stimulus on a 10 candela/m2 white background) states was performed using a modified automated perimeter and analyzed for rod and cone threshold elevation. Dark adaptometry was tested with 500- and 650-nm stimuli after a retinal exposure of 7.8 log scotopic-troland-seconds, estimated to bleach about 99% of the rhodopsin present, and recovery was measured until prebleach baseline dark-adapted(>3-hour) thresholds were attained. Details of these procedures have been published previously.13- 15 For the patients with central scotomas, bleaching and testing were performed using infrared visualization of the fundus with a modified fundus photoperimeter. Electroretinogram (ERG) photoresponses were evoked in the dark-adapted state with high-energy blue (2.3-4.6 log scotopic-troland-seconds) and red (1.4-3.6 log photopic-troland-seconds) stimuli and in the light-adapted (3.2 log troland white background) state with red (2.2-4.1 log photopic-troland-seconds) stimuli. A model of phototransduction activation consisting of the sum of rod and cone components was used to quantify the leading edges of dark-adapted waveforms; a model of cone phototransduction was used to quantify the leading edges of light-adapted waveforms. Details of recording and analysis methods have been published previously.16,17
The PCR product from exon 5 of the TIMP3 gene amplified from the proband (patient III-5) migrated in an aberrant electrophoretic pattern compared with normal control DNA samples run in parallel during SSCP analysis. Direct sequencing of the PCR product revealed a single base pair change, altering a conserved tyrosine to cysteine at amino acid position 172. This Y172C TIMP3 gene mutation cosegregates with the disease in generation III, which has the only living clinically affected members at this time; there were both mutation-positive and mutation-negative members in generation IV (Figure 1B).
The fundus photograph of patient III-5 at age 45 years (Figure 1C) is representative of the central retinal scarring from hemorrhagic macular degeneration found in affected members in the fourth and fifth decades of life. Fundus appearance and fluorescein angiography in patients III-3, 4, 6, and 7 documenting RPE abnormalities in the macula and midperipheral retina were previously reported.9 Five of the 6 affected patients had an acute loss of central vision in one eye between ages 26 and 29 years, with the second eye losing vision within 2 years of the first event. The affected half brother (patient III-1) lost central vision between ages 35 and 36 years. In generation IV, 4 younger asymptomatic family members (ages 7-21 years) carry the mutation and are at risk for developing the disease (Figure 1A).
Visual function studies in a subset of heterozygotes for the Y172C TIMP3 mutation are shown in Figure 2. Rod- and cone-mediated thresholds throughout the field of vision are shown for a 39-year-old patient (III-6) with a large central scotoma. Throughout the peripheral visual field were significant rod threshold elevations (mean, 2.0 log units); beyond the central scotoma, most cone thresholds were within normal limits. Patients III-3 and III-5 also showed more rod than cone threshold elevations in the peripheral visual field beyond their central scotomas. An asymptomatic 20-year-old heterozygote (patient IV-14) had normal results on eye examination and visual function tests.
Functional phenotype of heterozygotes with the Y172C TIMP3 mutation. A, Static threshold dark- and light-adapted perimetry in a patient representing a late stage of the disease. Elevation of rod and cone thresholds across the visual field are shown as gray-scale maps, with 16 levels representing 0 to 3 log units of threshold elevation. Black squares indicate no detection of stimuli. T, N, I, and S indicate temporal, nasal, inferior, and superior visual fields, respectively. B, Rod- and cone-isolated photoresponses (symbols connected by thin black lines) fitted with a model of phototransduction activation (thicker gray lines). Photoresponses evoked with blue 4.6 log scotopic-troland-second (ROD) and red 4.1 log photopic-troland-second (CONE) flashes are shown for each patient. Arrows on the y-axis denote the lower limit (mean − 2 SD) of normal maximum amplitude. C and D, Dark adaptation with 500-nm stimulus after a full bleach exposure in patients (symbols and thin lines) compared with the normal range (gray, thicker lines). Prebleach thresholds are shown preceding time zero; numbers represent test location in degrees in the T and N visual fields.
Rod and cone ERG photoresponses suggest that the abnormalities on psychophysical testing have a photoreceptor basis (Figure 2B). Patient IV-14 had normal rod and cone responses, whereas 3 older patients (patients III-3, 5, and 6) had rod maximum amplitudes reduced to approximately half of the mean normal value and normal or slightly reduced cone maximum amplitudes. Rod photoresponse sensitivities were within normal limits in 2 patients (III-6 and IV-14), whereas 2 other heterozygotes (patients III-3 and 5) had sensitivity losses of about 0.4 log units. Cone photoresponse sensitivities were within normal limits for all 4 patients.
Dark adaptation was tested at several different retinal loci in the 4 heterozygotes; representative functions obtained at ≥30° eccentric to the anatomical fovea are shown (Figure 2C and D). In patients IV-14 and III-6, dark-adaptation functions at 3 different loci were normal; in patient III-5, dark adaptation was borderline normal at 4 loci; and in patient III-3, it ranged from normal to abnormal at 4 loci tested. The abnormality, when present, consisted mainly of threshold elevation (Figure 2D).
Following the first association between a TIMP3mutation and SFD,2 several reports of other TIMP3 mutations in SFD have appeared.6,8 Almost all mutations documented in SFD to date, including Y172C, would be expected to alter residues in the C-terminal domain of the molecule. There is still no biological explanation of how mutation in an inhibitor of matrix metalloproteinase may be leading to decreased ECM turnover and extreme thickening of Bruch's membrane, the histopathological hallmark of SFD.18,19 Recent in vitro studies of 4 SFD mutations suggest that the pathogenesis is probably not caused by haploinsufficiency but by persistent increased function. Evidence has appeared that mutant TIMP-3 may be accumulating as a dimer and functionally contributing to a slowed turnover of the ECM.6 Immunocytochemical studies in a donor retina with SFD previously demonstrated an accumulation of TIMP-3 in Bruch's membrane.19 Recently, the need for a greater understanding of ECM biology to interpret disease was further boldasized when another counterintuitive observation was made in patients with multicentric osteolysis and arthritis syndrome, disorders characterized by an enhanced ECM breakdown. Causative mutations were found in the gene encoding matrix metalloproteinase-2,20 suggesting that like SFD this was another ECM disorder with a complex mechanism.21
Considering the onset ages reported for hemorrhagic macular degeneration in SFD families with other causative mutations,8 the family with the Y172C TIMP3 mutation is among those with an earlier onset of macular disease. The clinical manifestations in SFD are all likely to be secondary to the slowly progressive thickening of Bruch's membrane from the ECM imbalance discussed previously. Until the disease threshold is reached, the retinas of these patients are clinically and functionally normal. Choroidal neovascularization could be secondary to a hypoxic stimulus from the retina, which becomes separated by a critical distance from its choriocapillaris blood supply by ECM buildup. The photoreceptor abnormalities leading to extramacular vision loss may be secondary to RPE dysfunction.14 The finding of increased TIMP-3 content of Bruch's membrane with normal aging and in AMD7,22 raises the suspicion that this molecule may be a marker for pathological processes that lead to a disturbed ECM turnover. Abnormal binding and activity of TIMP-3 may be one of the aberrant pathways leading to many diseases of Bruch's membrane.
Submitted for publication July 17, 2001; final revision received October 25, 2001; accepted November 16, 2001.
This study was supported in part by grants EY-05627, EY-13203, and EY-12156 from the National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, Md; the Macular Disease Foundation, Virginia Beach, Va; the Macula Vision Research Foundation, West Conshohocken, Pa; Foundation Fighting Blindness Inc, Owings Mills, Md; and the F. M. Kirby Foundation, Morristown, NJ.
Dr Jacobson is a Research to Prevent Blindness (New York, NY) Senior Scientific Awardee, Drs Bennett and Cideciyan are Research to Prevent Blindness Special Scholars, and Dr Sheffield is an associate investigator of the Howard Hughes Medical Institute, Iowa City, Iowa.
We are grateful to M. Benegas, D. Hanna, J. Emmons, L. Gardner, Y. Huang, D. Marks, J. Huang, and C. Taylor for help with the conduct of this study.
Corresponding author and reprints: Samuel G. Jacobson, MD, PhD, Scheie Eye Institute, 51 N 39th St, Philadelphia, PA 19104 (e-mail: email@example.com).
Thank you for submitting a comment on this article. It will be reviewed by JAMA Ophthalmology editors. You will be notified when your comment has been published. Comments should not exceed 500 words of text and 10 references.
Do not submit personal medical questions or information that could identify a specific patient, questions about a particular case, or general inquiries to an author. Only content that has not been published, posted, or submitted elsewhere should be submitted. By submitting this Comment, you and any coauthors transfer copyright to the journal if your Comment is posted.
* = Required Field
Disclosure of Any Conflicts of Interest*
Indicate all relevant conflicts of interest of each author below, including all relevant financial interests, activities, and relationships within the past 3 years including, but not limited to, employment, affiliation, grants or funding, consultancies, honoraria or payment, speakers’ bureaus, stock ownership or options, expert testimony, royalties, donation of medical equipment, or patents planned, pending, or issued. If all authors have none, check "No potential conflicts or relevant financial interests" in the box below. Please also indicate any funding received in support of this work. The information will be posted with your response.
Some tools below are only available to our subscribers or users with an online account.
Download citation file:
Web of Science® Times Cited: 20
Customize your page view by dragging & repositioning the boxes below.
Enter your username and email address. We'll send you a link to reset your password.
Enter your username and email address. We'll send instructions on how to reset your password to the email address we have on record.
Athens and Shibboleth are access management services that provide single sign-on to protected resources. They replace the multiple user names and passwords necessary to access subscription-based content with a single user name and password that can be entered once per session. It operates independently of a user's location or IP address. If your institution uses Athens or Shibboleth authentication, please contact your site administrator to receive your user name and password.